Review by Karen Davis, PhD
The surprise and delight of a child meeting an animal at a farmed animal sanctuary reveals the evolutionary bond of kinship between humans and other
animals through the lens of these innocent, but not childish, encounters. That children are enchanted by a chicken, a turkey or a pig at a sanctuary, and
the reciprocity that springs between them, shows that our interspecies connections go far beyond just keeping a “pet.” This prospect is
explored, with significant implications, by William Crain in his new book The Emotional Lives of Animals and Children: Insights from a Farm Sanctuary.
Bill and Ellen Crain founded Safe Haven Farm Sanctuary in Dutchess County, New York in 2008. Bill, a psychology professor at The City College of New York,
and Ellen, a pediatrician in a large public hospital, purchased and renovated a broken-down farm with pasture. Their first rescued animal was a hen named
Miss Plucky. They then rescued several goats, sheep and chickens, about whom Bill writes insightfully with feeling. He say of nineteen beak-mutilated hens
who were being cared for by a homeless man in Harlem, that their irritability and “angry clucking sounds” in the early days of their arrival at
Safe Haven transformed into happy contentment only after they could forage outdoors as they pleased. It isn’t just freedom (space alone) that matters
to animals, Crain says of the hens’ transformation, “but the freedom to engage in natural behavior, that leads to deep contentment.”
Bill describes his and Ellen’s evolution, through their busy professional lives, toward a growing concern for animals. A bear hunt proposed by New
Jersey wildlife agencies drew Bill into taking a public stand against the hunt. A configuration of personal feelings and local situations threatening a
parcel of woods and the lives of animals, and an epiphany Bill had one bleak autumn day amid trees and birds, led to the founding of Safe Haven Farm
Bill explains that the decision to start a sanctuary for farmed animals included his desire to help and learn about the animals and to see if his
observations and discoveries regarding them could shed light on human behavior, especially that of children, with a particular focus on the bond between
children and (other) animals. The child who cares about animals, he writes, “grows up in a society of adults who are largely indifferent” to
animals and may even mistreat them purposely for pleasure, as exemplified by the canned bird hunts that are sponsored by a hunt club situated right next to
Safe Haven Farm Sanctuary, where several terrified ducks and partridges have sought and found refuge.
A key question posed by The Emotional Lives of Animals and Children is: what happens between childhood and adulthood that causes most children to
outgrow their primal delight in and empathy with animals and become detached, callous and indifferent toward them? Is it hormonal changes? Social
conditioning? Crain offers a variety of speculations, but the answer remains a mystery, and with it the wonder of what to do about humanity’s
detachment from and denigration of animals in a world run by the very adults who must have cared about animals when they were young, but lost the
connection growing up.
With the onset of adolescence, a child’s feeling for animals gives way to preoccupations with peers, boyfriends, girlfriends and the like. It is
tempting to focus on the dissociation of Western societies from Nature and animals – the effects of television, video games, less time spent outdoors
and so on, yet earlier times and other societies don’t necessarily provide an antidote. Belief in human superiority is not limited to
Judeo-Christianity or the Renaissance view of Man as the Measure of All Things, and while other times and places may have included animals more intimately
than ours in the form of totems, spirits and physical presences, this did not necessarily foster compassionate treatment of animals as a social norm.
Indeed, one of the worst fates for animals historically has been to be deemed “sacred,” and not all childhood behavior toward animals is
Crain discusses the English Romantic poet William Wordsworth’s tracing of his loss of childhood entrancement with Nature, but Wordsworth himself
doesn’t know why the glory faded with age; he can only evoke the loss and shore up the ruins. An argument between Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor
Coleridge centered on Wordsworth’s initial belief that living in Nature inspires positive emotions and values in people, whereas Coleridge argued
that only people who are predisposed to be “taught” and moved by Nature are susceptible to her beauty and “teachings.”
Wordsworth’s own chronicles of English rural life in his poetry depict poverty, squalor, despair and meanness along with some passionate examples of
human devotion and stoic suffering. It is notable that while Wordsworth was intoxicated by Nature as a child, animals figure very little in his poetry.
Flowers, rocks, trees and waterfalls affected him powerfully, but his poetry doesn’t bolster the view that a love of Nature invariably involves
caring about animals in a personal and morally active way.
Having run a sanctuary for chickens, turkeys, ducks, guinea fowl and a peacock for 30 years, I regard farmed animal sanctuaries as vitally important for
the animals, the caregivers and the public, who otherwise have little or no way of meeting and learning about chickens, turkeys, cows, pigs, goats and
other animals deemed “agricultural.” There are few or no ways outside a sanctuary for mainstream people to experience farmed animals in a
context of human love, care and respect for them as opposed to, say, a petting zoo, where a whole other atmosphere prevails. Where else are people going to
see farmed animals being happy? Between the food store and the animal farm, a false and demeaning rhetoric of agribusiness and advertising intervenes, and
it is almost exclusively through sanctuaries such as Safe Haven that visitors and readers of a book like The Emotional Lives of Animals and Children have a chance to perceive farmed animals appreciatively.
Photo by Richard Cundari
At the same time, a farmed animal sanctuary is an artificial environment whose refugees have come from more or less traumatic backgrounds and who, unlike
their counterparts in Nature, are not busy raising families and engaging in the daily activities that occupy and energize animals in the natural world,
which for them is not the “wild,” but their home. I don’t know how much we can ultimately learn about human nature or how to repair the
broken bonds between adult humans and other animals from a farmed animal sanctuary, but it is possible we can learn and do a lot, especially with the many
Internet sites and Facebook pages for sanctuaries that are now available and the videos being made of rescued farmed animals (Bill Crain has created some
lovely ones), even if we can’t physically visit sanctuary locations.
Tragically for animals and most people, a shadow – an iron curtain – falls between the child and the adult who share the same body and
presumably the same psyche, and while this severance is marked, its causes and cures are not clear. The loving vignettes of chickens, goats and other Safe
Haven residents, and of children helping animals and being moved to further altruistic endeavors as a result, are precious islands in this book as they are
in the world. How can we expand these islands? How can children’s love for animals be nurtured into adult values and public policies?
The Emotional Lives of Animals and Children
ponders these questions, including the thoughts of educators, psychoanalysts and ethologists. Sharing his personal and professional observations of the
animals at Safe Haven Farm Sanctuary, and interpreting what he sees in terms of a continuity of core emotions and behaviors linking other animals with
humans, Crain writes hopefully albeit wistfully, that “For animal defenders, the childhood attitudes offer encouragement. They indicate that a strong
affinity to animals is part of our nature, existing before the socialization process disrupts it. It is a basic resource we can try to regain.”
The Emotional Lives of Animals and Children
takes us to Safe Haven Farm Sanctuary, bringing to life Katie the hen, Cleo the partridge, Burdock the rooster, Boomer and Mattie the goats and the
relationships these animals share with one another and the human beings around them. The stories of their lives, their friendliness and fears, their
eagerness and intelligence, are all the more poignant against the background of misery from which they emerge to tell us something about themselves through
the voice of an adult whose own story of personal awakening holds promise.
--Karen Davis, United Poultry Concerns