Machipongo, VA - United Poultry Concerns President Karen Davis
sent a letter to President George W. Bush today urging that he permanently
ban the use of chickens to detect deadly chemicals in Iraq and replace
the birds with sophisticated chemical detection systems.
Noting that the first group of chickens intended to be placed on
vehicles to detect deadly chemicals in Iraq have died of unknown
causes, resulting in the use of chickens reportedly being suspended,
UPC’s President Karen Davis told President Bush that “Making
these birds participate in our wars is not only cruel and unjust;
it is a betrayal of the men and women who are serving under you.
“Under the stress of battle, causes of the birds’ death,
which may or may not be from toxic chemical exposure, will not be
identified quickly enough or with sufficient accuracy to enable
the soldiers to put on their gas masks at the crucial moment. Soldiers
in the Gulf War panicked when sentinel chickens died of the cold
in a sudden temperature drop. A genuine commitment to saving American
troops will not be achieved with cages full of terrified chickens
dying from innumerable indeterminate causes including starvation,
dehydration, and neglect.
“If they are so used, many of the chickens will die of stress
simply in being driven across a war-torn desert. They will die of
hunger, thirst, and oxygen deficiency. The chickens reported dead
in Kuwait last week were delivered to the 7th Regiment tightly packed
in boxes. They appear to have suffocated to death and probably also
died from lack of food and water while packed inside those boxes.
The Regiment told the press: ‘Nobody knows why they died .
. . And it didn’t help that nobody here really knows anything
about chickens.’ This does not bode well from a purely military
standpoint in addition to being completely inhumane.
“We regard the use of chickens to detect deadly chemicals
as a diversion for public and media entertainment that is more likely
to cost human lives than to save them. The only other excuse for
putting chickens in this predicament is Cheapness, not only of sentiment
but financial expenditure. Discussions about ‘going to any
expense to save American troops’ veer bizarrely into a defense
of using chickens instead of sophisticated chemical detection systems
because ‘chickens are cheap.’ If I were a soldier, I
would not like to think that my survival was being toyed with by
my government to provide comic relief to the public or to cut corners.
It is not only animal rights advocates who should loudly demand
an end to this irresponsible farce but every citizen and soldier.
“We accordingly request that you use your presidential power
to halt the use of chickens as chemical sentinels in this war and
in all other wars over which you may regrettably preside. If this
Administration cannot make peace with other countries, it can at
least protect American soldiers as much as possible by installing
high-tech chemical detection systems that actually work and that
soldiers can understand, operate, and respond to in an emergency.
You can exercise some practical compassion for the soldiers and
for the birds. Your own eloquent speech writer, Matthew Scully,
the author of the book Dominion: The Power of Man, the Suffering
of Animals, and the Call to Mercy, has observed in that book that
‘When substitute products [and technologies] are found, with
each creature in turn, responsible dominion calls for a reprieve.
. . . What were once ‘necessary evils’ become just evils’
“Please put this advanced ethical perception into practice
instead of relying on systems of death detection that, from a strictly
practical standpoint, are on a par with using flint stones instead
of computers with which to communicate.
“We thank you for your attention and look forward to your
Karen Davis, PhD, President
United Poultry Concerns, Inc.”
United Poultry Concerns is a nonprofit organization that promotes
the compassionate and respectful treatment of domestic fowl. http://www.upc-online.org